Tuesday, July 9, 2013

Book Review: War Trash


Ha, Jin. War Trash. Pantheon Books, 2004.

Reading an account, even a fictionalized one, of Asian prisoners held by the United States provides a clear look at commonalities in the prison experience facing military and civilian prisoners.  Ha Jin describes Chinese prisoners of war experiencing the same feelings of loneliness, isolation, and fear that American prisoners during the Vietnam War report in their memoirs.  Issues of living conditions, food supplies, collaboration, and physical abuse are also a constant concern of both the Chinese soldiers Ha Jin portrays and other prisoner memoirs.  The difference with this text is that it addresses the specific problems faced by soldiers of the People’s Liberation Army during and after the Korean War.
Issues specific to this setting included, but were not limited to, conflict between soldiers with Nationalist and Communist sympathies, disparity in treatment between the two groups by their American and South Korean captors, and worries over treatment by either Communist or Nationalist governments after the end of the war.  The novel’s protagonist, Yu Yuan, fell into a grey area between the Nationalists and Communists.  While not a member of the Communist Party, Yu also did not completely support Chiang Kai-Shek.  His credentials as a graduate of the Nationalist-affiliated Huangpu Military Academy caused Communists to view him with suspicions, while Nationalists assumed he would side with them.  Both sides desired his skills as an interpreter and pressured him to join him – the Nationalists going so far to torture and murder those who opposed him.
Though he disliked the Communists’ desire to control the thoughts and minds of his fellows, Yu feels that he must fulfill his filial duty to his Mother and fiancĂ©, and works to return to China at all costs.  As a result, he was one of the few Chinese prisoners to return.  Rather than receiving a hero’s welcome, the repatriated soldiers are condemned by the Communist Party, becoming pariahs in the homeland they fought to defend because they did not choose a glorious death.  By the time he returns, his mother is dead, and his fiancĂ© shuns him due to the stain on his reputation.  In contrast, Yu sees the prosperity of those who chose to relocate to Tiawan, and the welcome they receive when they return to China thirty years after the war.
As much as War Trash shows the commonality of the prisoner of war experience of soldiers of different nations, it shines a bright light on the specific challenges Chinese soldiers faced during the Korean War, particularly the demands of ideological purity and sacrifice placed on them by the Chinese Communist Party.  While fiction, Ha Jin draws not only on a variety of primary and secondary sources.  Since the work is dedicated to his father, a member of the PLA serving in Korea, it is sure that some of the events described come from his recollections of the period.  This means that while War Trash cannot be relied on for research purposes, it plays an important role in setting the mood of the conflict.


Wednesday, July 3, 2013

Long Exposure Vietnam War Photos Released

Along with the other strange occurrences of the long war in Vietnam, we now have night photography of a base camp responding to a lone sniper with overwhelming firepower to no result other than a blood trail (and fled enemy).  This is what two M-60 machine guns, an M-2 .50 cal. machine gun, and the 40 mm anti-aircraft guns on an M-42 Duster will get you (at night).  The photos are stunning for what they show (and imply) about the conduct of the war.

Long Exposure Vietnam War Photos Released


Monday, June 3, 2013

Queen Victory Papers Available through 23 June

For anyone interested...

ProQuest is proud to make all the personal journals of Queen Victoria available to search and read online. This unique resource, developed in partnership by the Bodleian Libraries, the Royal Archives and ProQuest, is freely available for the public to access Queen Victoria's Journals until June 23, 2013. 
The journals, which span Victoria’s lifetime and consist of 141 volumes numbering over 43,000 pages, have never been published in their entirety and previously were only accessible by appointment at the Royal Archives at Windsor Castle. In addition to autograph diaries begun by the youthful Princess Victoria, there are edited versions from her later years, redacted and transcribed by the Queen’s daughter, Princess Beatrice. 
All the journals are now available via this easy-to-use website and can be browsed and read online.  Pages from the journals can be searched by date or place of writing, and transcriptions of each page–searchable by keyword–are provided. The site includes an interactive timeline and drawings by Queen Victoria, along with selections from her sketchbooks.  Importantly, the site includes a number of essays about aspects of Queen Victoria’s life, authored by Sir Roy Strong, Laurence Goldman and Peter Ward-Jones among others. 
Public access to Queen Victoria’s Journals is available until June 23, 2013. A specialized version for libraries is available from ProQuest. 
http://www.queenvictoriasjournals.org

University of Alabama Commemorates Its First African-American Students

Fifty years after the first two African-American students enrolled at The University of Alabama following then-Gov. George Wallace’s unsuccessful “Stand in the Schoolhouse Door,” UA will commemorate that historic day and celebrate 50 years of progress with two public events – a program featuring speakers and musical performances on June 11, and an interfaith community prayer breakfast on June 7.

Tuesday, June 11, UA will host “Through the Doors: Courage. Change. Progress.” The program at Foster Auditorium is designed to recognize and honor the courage and dedication of Vivian Malone and James Hood, the two African-American students who enrolled at UA on June 11, 1963. It will include presentations by current UA students and alumni as well as musical performances. The event will begin with a reception in the Malone-Hood Plaza outside Foster Auditorium and will conclude by 7 p.m.

The public is also invited to an interfaith community prayer breakfast at 7:30 a.m., Friday, June 7 in the Bryant Conference Center. The program will celebrate the role of the faith community in the civil rights movement. Following commendations to Canterbury Episcopal Chapel and First African Baptist Church for their helpful roles in the events of 1963, the program will include performances by UA’s Afro-American Gospel Choir, a brief oral history of the local civil rights movement and prayers. While the breakfast is free, those planning to attend are asked to register at http://uaferguson.tix.com/Event.asp?Event=576940 by June 3.For more information about the events for June, click here.

Wednesday, May 22, 2013

Progress on My Lai

As anyone following my twitter feed noticed, this is My Lai week as I prepare to write my first two dissertation chapters.  I'll be trying to get the the first chapter on My Lai and the reactions of those present to the horrific events there on March 16, 1968, and part of my note-taking enterprise has been to tweet as I find interesting or important items in various books and documents.  Yesterday's reactions to Seymour Hersh's 1970 Harper's Magazine article were quite positive, as were those to Captain Jordan J. Praust's 1970 Military Law Review article.

Also important to my preparations to write have been Rives M. Duncan's dissertation, "What went Right at My Lai: An Analysis of the Roles of "Habitus" and Character in Lawful Disobedience".  Temple University seems to have been a veritable hotbed of My Lai scholarship during the 1990s, as one of yesterday's twitter responses from Pauline Kaurine revealed her dissertation "Agency and Character: A View of Action and Agency".  Neither History per se, but provide some good tools for examining how people at My Lai reacted, and even raise questions for how we judge their actions.  There's a definite conflict in interpretation between the two: Rives places the emphasis on individual, preexisting moral and professional mental frameworks, while Kaurine focuses on the nature of military character based on trust, honor, and oath-taking.  I'm not quite sure how to resolve the conflict, but both dissertations have important contributions to the discussion of why different people acted in the way that they did at My Lai.

The ideas in both intersect with the usual suspects, and I'm not talking about Calley or Medina.  Paul Meadlo seems to play a pivotal role in any discussion of what happened, as do Michael Bernhardt, Mike Terry, Gregory Olsen, Hugh Thompson, and Larry Colburn.  Rives Duncan argues that the social setting of Charlie company helps explain why some soldiers killed, raped, and pillaged at My Lai, while others didn't.  Duncan relies on Pierre Bourdieu's theories to explain why this happen, especially that of fields of power.  The military structure of power and rank form the social topology that determines which agents are influential in the social field.  The cultural capital of those agents also exerts influence on the social field - veteran combat soldiers, drill instructors, company commanders have more cultural capital to spend in influencing the social setting in which they operate, especially when dealing with inexperienced soldiers.

Duncan argues that social fields have their own mass and inertia, making them slow to change.  Change in an established social field can be so slow that it is virtually unnoticed when it occurs.  This is part of what happened in Vietnam - the values and norms of the soldiers changed as their experience of guerrilla war and untrustworthy leadership rubbed against the edges of the regular army's habitus.  Problems arose in Vietnam partially because the values and norms of the soldiers changed, but the written codification of how they were expected to behave did not - the laws of war did not change to match the environment that soldiers found themselves in.  Expected soldierly behavior in Vietnam changed from what the formal military culture indicated it should be.

The result was that the troops in Charlie Company who did not participate in atrocities at My Lai were the outliers, not the ones who engaged in rape and murder.  Duncan believes that nonparticipants didn't due to various forms of isolation from the rest of Ernest Medina's troops that day.  The isolation of nonparticipants was social, religious, geographic, and professional - these are the factors that Duncan argues led some soldiers not to participate in atrocities in My Lai.  Unfortunately, nonparticipation in atrocities further separated those soldiers from the group, and may have put their lives in further jeopardy because they lost the trust and loyalty of their comrades.  One example of this predates the massacre - according to his testimony before the Peers Commission, Dennis Bunning had used his large size to stop rapes several times before March 16, 1968, but other members of Charlie Company threatened to kill him if he continued.

Duncan identified several types of factors that lead soldiers to resist unlawful orders - personal factors, situational factors, and "other" factors.  Personal factors include strong religious faith that instills a moral code so ingrained that is seems normal or natural to the individual.  People act on these moral codes without conscious thought because they are practiced in real life, not just theories, to the point that they may be seen as just part of a society's values.  Situational factors include where the person is when the illegal order is given, and how far the order deviates from normal acceptable practices.  An order to kill unarmed women and children fits this category, as does being on the peripheries of the action (which might allow soldiers to resist an order without appearing to).  Other factors that Duncan identified as being part of soldiers' resistance to unlawful orders included education, maturity, age, and experience in the military.

Some soldiers were able to fully or partially resist orders to shoot civilians at My Lai due to their location in the village - Bunning, Olsen, Carter, Maples, Dursi, and Bernhardt all benefited from their relative distance from Lt. Calley and their comrades who were shooting civilians.  Chronological distance also helped some soldiers more easily avoid unlawful orders from Calley.  Bernhardt and Partsch were delayed while they examined an ammunition box while the rest of 1st Platoon assaulted the village.  When they did enter My Lai, Bernhardt did so with his rifle slung - he didn't actively resist orders to shoot, but was also not in a position to kill.  Similarly, the delayed entry of 3rd Platoon kept it from participating in atrocities as much as 1st and 2nd platoons.  Some members of 3rd Platoon were horrified by what they saw - Leonard Gonzalez notably vomited on encountering the bodies.

Other soldiers used tactics of avoidance, including leaving the group, shooting animals, or misunderstanding orders to resist at My Lai.  Duncan reports that LaCross, Lee, and Pendleton shot only at livestock, which gave the appearance that they were participating in the slaughter, but kept them from shooting innocent civilians.  Ronald Grzesik later claimed that he didn't understand what Calley meant when told to "finish off" a group of villagers that he was guarding.  Others' , like Sergeant Isaiah Cowen simply wandered off.  Gregory Olsen's M60 machine gun kept jamming, which allowed him to stop and move off to the flanks of his platoon to avoid killing.

James Dursi took a greater risk by refusing a direct order from Calley to open fire, saying that he was willing to go to jail over it.  He led his team away from the lieutenant to avoid getting caught up in the action.  Robert Maples similarly refused to use his M60 on a line of villagers that Calley wanted killed, ultimately dropping the weapon, which Calley seized and used anyway, and event corroborated by Mike Terry.  Bunning, who had earlier stopped rapes in progress, refused his squad leader's order to open fire, and found himself moved to guard the flank like Olsen.

These acts of resistance are primarily passive or negative in nature - the men involved did little to stop their fellows from murdering or raping the residents of My Lai.  Only Warrant Officer Hugh Thompson answered the call of duty to put a halt to the killing in My Lai.  After numerous attempts to contact the ground forces and complaints to other helicopters that were recorded in Duc Pho and Cu Chi, Thompson landed his scout helicopter and confronted Calley, ordering his door gunner and crew chief to open fire if American troops moved to kill more civilians.  Beyond this, Thompson entered a bunker to retrieve women and children hiding there to save them from grenades, and waded into a ditch with Larry Colburn to rescue a small child.  Thompson even cajoled the crews of the helicopter gunships over My Lai to land and evacuated some of the wounded.  Not satisfied with this, he filed a formal complaint with his superior officers, coming close to insubordination while doing so, and discussed the massacre with 11th Brigade chaplain Captain Carl Cresswell.

Duncan argues that individual habitus overrode any military training for the men that resisted participating in Charlie Company's acts in My Lai, saying that it took great courage for any soldier to disobey a direct order in combat.  Paul Meadlo, one of the more interesting figures of the massacre and its aftermath is an example of those whose character led them to follow authority above other considerations.  His initial response at My Lai was to gather and guard civilian prisoners and play with the children to keep them occupied - he believed that this seemingly normal procedure was what Calley had intended.  As a result, Meadlo was surprised when ordered to kill the villagers that he was guarding.  As the day progressed, he said he didn't want anything to do with the killing, but Calley pressed him to do it. Shooting civilians when ordered to by Calley until overwhelmed by the horror of it, Meadlo still had a distinct sense of morals, as evidenced in his candid television interviews, in which he was matter of fact and didn't shirk responsibility for his role in the massacre.  He testified that his understanding was that if he disobeyed orders in combat, he could be summarily executed, or jailed at hard labor.  Meadlo also contended that based on his interactions with veteran soldiers, his understanding of the war in Vietnam was that permissible behavior was different in guerrilla wars because everyone could be the enemy.

Gregory Olsen, Mike Terry, Hugh Thompson, and Michael Bernhardt also stand out as soldiers whose individual characters played a large role in their actions at My Lai.  Olsen and Terry were devout Mormons, and used to being seen as different as a result.  Duncan contends that religion was a determining factor in both Olsen's behavior and how people viewed him.  Mormons grew up living in a culture that was generally opposed to them, but adhered to their faith anyway.  That experience gave Olsen and Terry practice in taking a stand for their own values.  Olsen had previously expressed his concerns about the morals and disciplines of his comrades when they abused captives, and acted to avoid the carnage in My Lai.  He later testified that he saw no plausible way to report violations of the Geneva Conventions during the attack.

Terry was devout enough that he refused to use profanity even when quoting others under oath.  He was quite willing to be considered different, and other soldiers remember him as prone to questioning everything in order to understand the purpose of what he was told to do.  At My Lai, Terry made a gut-wrenching decision to kill severely wounded civilians who had no hope of receiving medical aid, and was tormented by that decision afterward.  In this case, a soldier technically violated the laws of war, but made what he believed was the most moral choice in a bad situation by acting to alleviate pain and suffering.

Religious motives are also frequently assigned to Hugh Thompson, who was a Baptist in the process of studying to become a confirmed Episcopalian.  Even before My Lai, Thompson was seen as a pilot who was willing to aggressively fly to fight the enemy, but would only fire if he saw a weapon and had a clear shot.  Coming from the deep South, Thompson was sometimes described as being racially prejudiced, but still acting like a professional.  These attributes were accompanied by an almost idealistic view of the American character - he reportedly said that he couldn't abide what happened at My Lai because Americans were supposed to be the "good guys", and didn't do those sorts of things.

Like Paul Meadlo, Michael Bernhardt represents another outlier.  He was alienated from Charlie Company from the beginning, joining the group after it had been together for awhile.  Bernhardt later testified that he just didn't understand the motivations of his comrades in the company, who were described as average soldiers, or grunts.  They were a group quite different from his own experience - he had attended LaSalle Military Academy, and attended summer training conducted by Green Berets, and received LRRP training before joining Charlie Company.  Bernhardt was a STRAC soldier - he did things by the book, and believed that the purpose of the war was not just to kill the enemy, but to induce them to stop fighting.  He saw My Lai as having no strategic purpose, and being counter-productive because it would push Vietnamese to support the communists.

Sunday, May 19, 2013

Culpability and War Crimes

While review my My Lai materials for the first chapter of my dissertation, I came across Brigadier General Howard H. Cooksey's response to Tom Glen, who served in the 4/3rd Infantry, 11th Brigade, Americal Division.  Glen had written MACV Commander Creighton Abrams as he left Vietnam for home about abuses of Vietnamese by American soldiers.  Cooksey's comments get to the core of my dissertation since I'm writing more about witnesses to atrocities than the alleged perpetrators:
It is the duty of every American soldier to ensure that [the Geneva Conventions] are upheld, and the responsibility of violations rests in a certain measure upon those who do not report violations they have witnessed.  You imply that this goes on at other than the individual level; yet, there is always a higher headquarters to which violations can be referred and channels exist to which these reports can be made.  You ask: "Does his presence in a combat zone and his possession of a rifle absolve a soldier from moral responsibility?" The answer to that is, of course, No.  But neither is a person who keeps silent when he witnesses a war crimes absolved of responsibility for that crime because he did not actively participate in it.*
This is certainly the correct legal, moral, and ethical response, but when considered in relation to My Lai, seems a bit naive.  Hugh Thompson and Chaplain CPT Creswell both reported the massacre to higher authority, and radio intercepts of the conversations among the helicopter pilots were made, but the officers of Task Force Barker were successful in their cover-up of what happened at My Lai.  Only letters to Congress and media coverage brought any action.  The dozens of other men who witnessed the massacre, including those who refused to take part, did nothing to report the massacre to the authorities, and themselves took part in hushing things up when COL Oran K. Henderson and LTC Frank Barker conducted their sham of an investigation of their own units.  What I'm trying to get at is how those guys rationalized their noninvolvement and lack of intervention when they witnessed what were clearly war crimes.


Michael Bilton and Kevin Sim, Four Hours in My Lai. New York: Viking, 1992.

Saturday, May 18, 2013

Online Collection of Soviet War Posters at the University of Nottingham

Manuscripts and Special Collections at the University of Nottingham (in collaboration with Web Technologies and the Department of Russian and Slavonic Studies), have created a website for the display of its collection of Soviet war posters, curated by Cynthia Marsh, Emeritus Professor of Russian Drama and Literature: http://windowsonwar.nottingham.ac.uk/


The online exhibition examines the creation, intentions and use of the posters in great detail. Each poster is placed within ‘stories’ to provide context and simple routes through the site in a horizontal layout echoing the experience when visiting a real exhibition. They are featured full screen with hotspots and side panels providing information on the war context, design, artists and writers involved in their creation, giving a broad historical commentary. Audio (readings of the verse featured on some of the posters) and video (interviews with various members of the team) are also being added.

Eleonora Nicchiarelli
Digital Development Officer
Manuscripts and Special Collections
University of Nottingham
King's Meadow Campus
Lenton Lane
Nottingham
NG7 2NR
Tel: 0115 84 68649

Email: eleonora.nicchiarelli@nottingham.ac.uk